Grilled Apple Cheddar Panini Sandwich

This grilled apple cheddar panini sandwich is a fun twist on the classic grilled cheese sandwich. Perfect lunch for a Fall day!

This recipe was originally posted in 2013, but has since been updated.

Up in these northern parts we like to pair our slice of apple pie with a slice of cheddar instead of a dollop of ice cream. I talk like this is normal, but in reality I’ve never even had the combo. Give me the ice cream, cheese belongs on a pizza pie not an apple.

In any sense, I thought I would see what all the fuss was about by trying it in a sandwich form. In honor of my good friend Kay-ran’s favorite quote..”A pie without cheese is like a hug without a squeeze.”

What makes this apple cheddar sandwich delicious and healthy

• fresh apple (I like McIntosh, honeycrisp, or cortland)
• whole wheat bread
• shredded sharp cheddar cheese
• cinnamon

How to make this grilled apple cheddar sandwich

Start by thinly slicing your fresh apple of choice. You won’t need the whole apple, so you either slice half, make a couple sandwiches, or make like me, and snack on the rest!

Add 1/4 cup to 1/2 cup of shredded cheddar cheese (depending on how cheesy you like your sammich) between two slices of whole wheat bread. I’m a big fan of whole wheat peasant bread, or even whole wheat sourdough! To one slice, add fresh apple slices, and sprinkle with 1/8 to 1/4 teaspoon of cinnamon.

Heat a large skillet over medium-low heat, and coat with a good dose of cooking spray. Sandwich both slices of bread together, and add to the skillet. Top with a heavy pan, like a cast iron, or you can also use another skillet topped with a large can to weigh down the skillet, and press your sandwich panini-style. Alternatively, use a panini press. Cook on each side for 2-3 minutes, or until golden brown, and crispy.

Pro Tips

• You can also use sliced cheddar cheese instead of shredded. I just like how shredded evenly melts. Just make sure you add cheese to both slices of bread to prevent any sogginess.
• Switch up the type of apple you use for a different flavor, or even try with sliced pears.

FAQs

I don’t have a panini press! Can I still make this?

Absolutely! You can cook in a skillet, and simply top your sandwich with a heavy pan, like cast iron, or use another skillet weighed down with a couple large cans or jars to get that panini-style press.

How long does this sandwich last?

Around these parts, about 5 minutes. 🙂 It is really best enjoyed immediately after cooking, but if you do have leftovers, I would keep at most overnight. Reheat in a dry skillet over medium-low heat for 2-3 minutes per side, or until warmed through.

Can I use any other kinds of cheese?

The sky is the limit. If you’re looking for other fruit grilled cheese inspo, you can check out this Blueberry Basil & Goat Cheese Panini too!

Money-Saving Tips for this Grilled Apple Cheddar Sandwich

Buy in season. Make the most of apple season, or what apples are on sale that week to maximize freshness, flavor, and cost.

Buy in bulk. If you use cinnamon frequently, purchasing a larger container instead of smaller can be a more cost-effective option.

more sandwich recipes:

Blueberry Basil & Goat Cheese Panini

Broccoli Cheddar Waffle Grilled Cheese

Black Pepper & Cranberry Turkey Sandwich

Did you make this recipe? Leave me a comment and a rating to let me know how it came out!

Pin this to your Sandwiches board!

Print